Showing posts with label Searcy County. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Searcy County. Show all posts

Saturday, February 23, 2019

The James and William Holmes Family of Tennessee, Arkansas, Missouri, and Texas

Almost as soon as I started getting serious about genealogy about 10 years ago, I ran into a quandary with my Holmes ancestry. Actually, I ran into several quandaries surrounding this family and it has taken years to unravel them and straighten everything out as best I can.

I feel strongly that my information on this Holmes family is as complete and accurate as any that exists in the world, and I feel obligated to share this information with fellow Holmes family researchers. I can answer numerous questions that have plagued those of us that have studied this confounding family for generations, and I can attach members to this family that most (if any) researchers have up to now not known belonged to this family. 

There are so many questions about this family that it is difficult to know where to begin. I guess the best place to start is with the two primary progenitors of this family and what we know about them, and then work our way forward.

In early Perry County, Tennessee we first find our two men of intrigue together: William and James Holmes. They both signed a petition in 1819 to have Perry County formally formed, and they appear in the 1820 Census there. It has been unclear to many what these two men's relationship was to one another. Because they appear to have an age gap of over 15 years, some have presumed them to be father and son. Others believed them to be brothers, but no document ever satisfactorily specifies their relationship.

In 1829, James applied for a pension for service in the Revolutionary War. A full transcription of his application can be found here: http://revwarapps.org/r5171.pdf. I will not copy all of it, but I want to make note of certain bits of information.

His application was made out of Perry County. He reported that he was a private in the company of a Captain Benjamin Tutt of a South Carolina unit, the name of which he could not recall. He reports to have served along with his father, William Holmes. It is worth noting that an apparent cousin, also named William Holmes, appears to have served in the same unit; in his pension, a witness on his behalf says that he was enlisted by the elder William Holmes, his uncle. [Pension of the second William Holmes--see testimony of William Couch: http://revwarapps.org/w27864.pdf].

Two of the witnesses to William's initial claim are noteworthy: Absalom Denton and William Holmes. They attested that James "is generally reputed and believed to have been a private Soldier in the Revolution." The Denton family are closely allied with this one, and we will discuss them further later on. A more "fun" note is that two of his witnesses (no apparent relation) were from Dickson County, Tennessee; the Justice of the Peace that signed their statement was a John W. Napier, who coincidentally is a cousin of mine on another branch of my family.

In a letter to the Revolutionary Claims office, James states: "You will perceive by a search of the records, that I have drawn my bounty land. You will also see that William Holloms, my Father, who served at the same time, and in the same Regiment with me has drawn his bounty land, or at least I drew it, as [heir] to him." Interestingly, none other than Colonel David "Davy" Crockett, then a United States Representative of the State of Tennessee, took an interest in the case, and James authored a letter to him. To Col. Crockett he writes: "Colonel you know me very well, I have always done all for you that in my power lay, and always shall, and I want you to help me out if you possibly can, and it shall ever be recollected with gratitude. – Please write to me and let me know how you come on, and accept of the best wishes of your old friend for your prosperity and success, and everything you may undertake that is good."

In 1836, he reports being 68 years old, which means he was born approximately 1768. He reported that he "that he entered into the Army of the United States in the year of '79 with Lieutenant Farrow [Thomas Farrar] and served in the Regiment in the South Carolina line of the Continental line under ...Capt. Benjamin Tutt...he can recollect he left the service in the Spring of 1782; he served two years and a half." That would make him roughly 11 years old when he joined up and roughly 14 years old when he left. This would not be completely unheard of, but still quite uncommon. Perhaps since he was with his father this was allowed.

In 1843, James stated he was 75 years old, which again has him being born about 1868. At this time, he believes he enlisted in 1780 and left in 1783, stating "he enlisted with the advice and consent of his father when a small boy just barely able to bear Arms when he first entered the service in the same company with his father. Then he marched from Greenville district to Seneca a fort on Savannah River. At which place he staid and not far from it for the term of one year and then was furloughed and he returned home to see his mother and to get some better health and [stayed] some few weeks and then returned to the Fort agreeable to his Furlough and there remained in actual service for near one year longer and was again Furloughed and went again home and returned agreeable to furlough and some time after he was taken sick and his father hired a man to serve in his place and that the Fort Seneca was surrendered and before he recovered the War ended. "

It does not appear James was ever successful in receiving his pension, though he reports having received his Bounty Land Warrant. Apparently without any comrades to corroborate his service and no service record, the pension office found his serving as an 11-15 year old boy unlikely.

But all of this gives us useful information--his father's name, his age, his home state, and proof of his association with Absalom Denton and William Holmes (the younger one, and not his cousin from South Carolina).

The 1819 petition to form Perry County gives us additional noteworthy names. Names of all the signers can be found here: http://tngenweb.org/perry/1819-petition/. There are some attention-worthy disclaimers that the transcriber provided:

- Original Material in Poor Condition.  Best Copy Available;

- Spelling is transcribed as was written in the original record;

- This is an interesting piece. From my analysis, the petition includes some who may not be of legal age and there are a few duplicate names; the spelling of names was quite creative. some names were duplicated but there may have been some junior/senior situations.  This is copied to the best of my ability, retaining spelling and pages. You will note that there seems to be several [duplicates] of names. In other words, the same names are on more than one page.

38th and 39th on the list are William and James Holmes, one right after the other. Further on we have the following noteworthy names, including several duplicates, as the transcriber mentioned, and some names of persons I am certain were not of legal age of majority (which was 21 at this time):

Benjamin Denton
Absalom Denton
Samuel Denton
Benjamin Denton
James Holmes
Samuel Holmes
Denton Shipman
Isaac Shipman
Abraham Denton Sr.
Abraham Denton Jr.
Samuel Denton Sr.
Samuel Denton Jr.
Absalom Denton
Jacob Shipman
Isaac Shipman Sr.
Benjamin Holmes
John Shipman
Isaac Denton
Abraham Holmes
James Holmes Jr.
James Denton
James Shipman

James Holmes Jr. would have been about 12 in 1819. If Benjamin Holmes was 21, he was only just. Abraham Holmes would have been about 13. Samuel Holmes would have been about 17. And it appears one of our James Holmeses signed twice.

Another petition in 1819 requesting a "right of preference" be granted to an Andrew Stobough Sr. includes the following names: William Holmes, Samuel Holmes, Benjamin Holmes, Denton Shipman, Isaac Shipman Jr., Shipman Denton, Samuel Denton Jr., Abraham Denton, Samuel Denton Sr., Benjamin Denton, and Absalom Denton. Source: https://lists.rootsweb.com/hyperkitty/list/denton.rootsweb.com/thread/29110146/

Between 1820 and 1850 many Holmeses would appear in records in Perry and Wayne counties, Tennessee and later Searcy and Van Buren counties, Arkansas, and Stoddard County, Missouri, being the three primary places our Holmeses migrated to after leaving Perry County. The trouble has been ascertaining where each of these Holmeses belong--whether as James's son, William's son, or NEITHER. Up until I collected the records I have now succinctly outlining one of the two families, there was only ever one record found that firmly established what relationship two Holmes men shared. Everything else has been conjecture. We Holmes researchers had no choice but to make our best educated guesses on where each Holmes man belonged, but we never had solid proof--until now that is.

I am now going to list the various men that at one point or another have been assumed to be the sons of James or William Holmes, what we know about their age (if anything), and in what records they first appear that has led to their being lumped with our Holmes men. You'll find each and every one of them applied to either James or William in online trees, and many if not most are applied to both in one tree or another--that is the extent of the confusion and widespread guesswork that has occurred on this matter. There is no particular order.

1. Benjamin Holmes - Age unknown/likely born circa 1798. Sworn Chain Carrier in 1821 deed from Absalom Denton to William Young and signer of the 1819 petition to form Perry County. Does not appear in 1830 Census or 1840 Censuses or known tax lists.

2. Samuel Holmes - Born circa 1802. Signed 1819 petition, appears in 1830 Census in Perry County. Appears to be the Samuel Holmes in neighboring Wayne County on tax lists in 1836 and 1838 and on the 1840 Census there.

3. Abraham "Abram" Holmes - Born circa 1806. This guy right here has caused a large amount of confusion because he was enumerated twice in the 1830 Census and purely to annoy genealogists, I'm sure, continually switched between using the name Abraham and the name Abram at will. The 1830 Census caused some to believe there were two Abrahams, or that he was just "Abram" and the other was a mis-transcription of "Absalom", but I do believe--like many before him--that Abraham was simply enumerated twice. Once, he is next door to the aforementioned Samuel. The other time he is quite near James. In one household, it is him, his apparent wife, and three small children. The other appears to be him and his wife with two 10-14 year old girls. No children born before 1831 have been identified for Abraham; that's not to say he didn't have any, but they have not been found. He was too young to have had daughters over age 10 by 1830, so I feel that one household has children or step-children or nieces/nephews/other relations, and the other is has what are possibly nieces but more likely sisters of his wife or other relations. I do not believe there were two Abrahams in this family. He also appears on the 1837 tax list for Perry County.

4. Benjamin Holmes - Born circa 1816. "But wait, isn't he the first man in this list, and didn't you say he doesn't appear in censuses or tax lists?" Yes, because unlike with Abraham, there actually were two Benjamin Holmeses--and I will prove it. He appears in the 1837 tax list for Perry County and the 1840 Census for Perry County.

5. James Holmes - Born 1807. This is James Holmes II of three total, including the aforementioned eldest James. He appears in the 1837 tax list and the 1840 Census, both in Perry County.

6. James Holmes - Born circa 1816. Yes, a third one. James III appears in the 1837 tax list for Perry County (as later records would prove, he apparently had just turned 21 in that tax year) but not the 1840 Census. It is also possible that the eldest James paid taxes twice if he owned enough property to justify it; regardless, there was still a third James as proven by the 1840 Census. There were three enumerated James Holmeses, their ages being 70-79, 30-39, and 20-29. This would be the youngest of the three.

7. Absalom Holmes - Born circa 1813. My ancestor. Absalom's spelling is sometimes deviated to Absalum or Apsolom or some other variation. Some crazy people want to add the first name "Asa" to him just because they like it and think it sounds cool? I guess? I am only guessing because there is no formal record in existence in the universe or in the history of time that indicates his first name was anything but Absalom. No Absalom A. or A. Absalom on records. No formal document calling him Asa or alluding to such a name. Someone somewhere in the last few decades saw a record for an Asa Holmes, assumed it was our Absalom, and decided his name was Asa Absalom. Dozens if not hundreds of copy-and-paste genealogists followed suit and put that name in their trees. So once and for all I cannot make myself more plain: There was no Asa Absalom Holmes--at least not in this family. The Absalom Holmes that married Julia Gambill, Olive Hollis, and at least two women named Elizabeth and lived in Perry County, TN, Van Buren County, AR, Newton County, MO, and Limestone County, TX WAS NOT AND NEVER WILL BE NAMED ASA ABSALOM HOLMES AND IF YOUR TREE INDICATES OTHERWISE, IT IS WRONG AND YOU CANNOT PROVIDE A SINGLE DOCUMENT PROVING OTHERWISE. 

Please don't absorb information out of people's family trees without verifying its accuracy; that way we don't end up with COUNTLESS online family trees disrespectfully applying an incorrect/made-up first name to a person. I'm sure you hope that on future family trees someone doesn't give you the name Bob before your actual name, right? Just for no reason. Like I would be Bob Nathan Vaughan Marks in dozens of family trees until the end of time because some ridiculous person wanted to make up a name because it sounded fun. If you don't want genealogy karma to come back and bite you, it would be wise to verify things like this when you notice, "Huh. This guy appears in 5 Census records and many other documents, and not one of them shows his name as Asa. Gee, I wonder why that could be?!?!?!?"

There, I feel better now that that is out of my system. ABSALOM appears in the 1837 Perry County tax list and subsequently in the 1840 Census of Wayne County, where he reportedly married his second wife Olive Hollis in the same year.

8. John Holmes - Age unknown. He appears in the 1837 Perry County tax list. He could be the John Holmes in the 1830 Census for neighboring Wayne County, where there was a separate Holmes family [http://tngenweb.org/wayne2/1830-census/]. It has not been clear if this John belongs to our family or not. He was not located after 1837; there was a John Holmes in Texas in the 1850 Census born 1811, but there is no indication they are one in the same. If he paid taxes in 1837, he was at least 21, so he would have been born 1816 or earlier.

9. Welcome Holmes - Born circa 1814. He appears in the 1840 Census in Searcy County, Arkansas. He appears to be the first member of this family to have come to Arkansas. His connection to our family is proven by his connection to the aforementioned Benjamin Holmes--the one listed number 4. On 11 Jun 1915, the Van Buren County Democrat out of Clinton, Arkansas published a letter to the editor from a William D. Holmes. He was the son of Benjamin Holmes (No. 4) and his letter discussed the early days of the county. He stated he moved with his father to Searcy County in 1844, and to Van Buren County five years later. He writes, "I remember helping my father Benjamin Holmes, my Uncle Week Holmes (Welcome Holmes) and Joe Barnes build the first jail house ever built in Van Buren County and it was built at Clinton. I was 16 or 18 years old at the time." This proves his connection to our family, and also was the aforementioned only discovered record (up to this point) that specifies a relationship between any of the Holmes men on this list (whether they are brothers, cousins, or uncles/nephews). 

10. Jacob L. Holmes - Born circa 1819. He first appears in the 1850 Census in Campbell, Searcy, Arkansas, where many of our Holmeses would be enumerated at one point or another. He is not found in other widely-available records before or after this point.

11. George W. Holmes - Born circa 1815. He certainly appears in the 1850 Census in Campbell, Searcy, Arkansas, the aforementioned place where Jacob and others are found in 1850. He is almost certainly the Washington Holmes that appears in the 1838 tax list of Wayne County right next to Samuel Holmes [http://tngenweb.org/wayne2/category/1838taxes/] because in 1840 his household is enumerated directly adjacent to the household of the aforementioned Absalom Holmes; Samuel is enumerated a few pages away.

12. William Holmes - Born circa 1823. He appears for the first time in the 1850 Census in Campbell, Searcy, Arkansas.

So now we have 12 men to try and place as sons of either James or William. While some mingle closely enough together to assume they're brothers (George and Absalom, Samuel and James III), and in one case we know the younger Benjamin and Welcome are brothers, we have really had no way to definitively divvy them all up between their respective families. If like some, you believe the elder William is a son of James--highly unlikely since the 1850 Census says James was born in 1783, and as we have established James was born in 1768, he would have been 15 when William was born--then the remaining sons of James would be uncles to William's sons. If James and William are brothers, then these men are either brothers or 1st cousins to one another.

I am going to lay out the households for James and William in 1820 and 1830 to give us an idea of how difficult this task has been. Then I will provide the document that definitively pieces together one family which in turn allows us to determine the members of the other family.

James Holmes - 1820 Census - Perry County, Tennessee
Males under 10 - 4 (at least 6 of the listed men, with the possibility of John, fall in this age range)
Males 10-15 - 2 (at least 2 of the men fit in this category, with John also possibly fitting)
Males 16-18 - 1 (Only Samuel Holmes fits this enumeration)
Males 16-25 - 1 (Only the elder Benjamin Holmes fits this enumeration)
Males 45 and over - James, who would have been 52
Females under 10 - 1
Females 10-15 - 1
Females 26-44 - James's wife, who if closer to 44 could be the mother of all these sons, but if very much younger would likely be a second wife

William Holmes - 1820 Census - Perry County, Tennessee
Males under 10 - 3 (again, at least 6 and as many as 7 fit this enumeration)
Males 10-15 - 1 (at least two and maybe three fits)
Males 26-44 - William, who would have been 37
Females 10-15 - 1
Females 26-44 - William's wife

James Holmes - 1830 Census - Perry County, Tennessee
Males 10-14 - 2 (At least 3 fits, not including John)
Males 15-19 - 2 (At least 3 fits, not including John)
[James not enumerated for some reason]
Females 10-14 - 1
Females 50-59 - James's wife. This and the previous enumeration indicating she was age 44 or younger indicates she was born roughly between 1775-1780, meaning she was likely the mother of all his sons with the possible exception of the oldest son.

William Holmes - 1830 Census - Perry County, Tennessee
Males 5-9 - 1 (only one fits this--the younger William)
Males 10-14 - 1 (At least 3 fits, not including John)
Males 15-19 - 1 (At least 3 fits, not including John)
Males 20-29 - 1 (At least 3 fits, not including John, but Abraham has his own household)
[William also not enumerated for some reason]
Females Under 5 - 1
[William's wife also not enumerated, though he could have been widowed and remarried]

So what can we infer from these records and what we know about each man?

- Samuel was born about 1802; William about 1783. While it is not impossible for someone to have children before the age of majority, it would be quite uncommon. Therefore, I think it is safe to assume Samuel was the son of James and not William.

- William had only one son who was 10-15 in 1820; since that son appears to still be living with him in 1830 and Abraham is on his own, we can infer that Abraham was likely the son of the eldest James, and therefore James II (or possibly the the mysterious John) was likely the son of William.

- As mentioned, the younger William only fits as the son of the older William and the older Benjamin only fits as the son of James. Therefore, we can infer that the other Benjamin would be the son of William, and since we know Welcome was the brother of Benjamin, he too would be William's son.

Again, these are all conjecture until we have a solid document proving the outline of this family. Fortunately for Holmes researchers everywhere, I have some--courtesy of the archives of Stoddard County, Missouri.

Samuel Holmes is our savior. He is still in Wayne County in 1850. Living with him he has James Holmes III, James's apparent wife Elizabeth, and a 2 year old enumerated as a male, but also enumerated as being named Susannah. Based on the records I am going to share here, I believe "Susannah" was actually named Samuel. By 1860, Samuel had removed to Stoddard County, Missouri where he resided with James and the younger Samuel. It is unclear if James III was widowed or divorced.

Interestingly, in 1830 Samuel is enumerated with 3 males under age 5 and two females 5-9 in his household--but no wife is enumerated. I'm not looking too hard at that since, as previously mentioned, neither James nor William were enumerated in their respective households in the same year and same county. I think the Perry County census guy was really slacking off that year.

By 1840 in Wayne County, Samuel is enumerated by himself. So a number of things could have happened. Perhaps he was caring for children that were not his own--nieces/nephews or step-children. Or maybe all of his children died in a terrible occurrence. We really have no way of knowing for sure, but what we do know is that when he died in 1865, his heirs were determined to be his siblings, indicating that he either had no children or if he did, those children had died.

Samuel held extensive land holdings at the time of his debt. He both owed a number of debts and was owed a number of debts at the time of his death. As such, there were extensive proceedings concerning his estate. It appears he died in intestate in mid-1865 and Alison E. Carter was appointed his estate's administrator on 2 Jun 1865. [https://sites.rootsweb.com/~mostodd2/probate/pro51.htm] At some point between that date and 13 Feb 1866, Henry H. Bedford was appointed the estate's new administrator, and on that date the administrators became Abraham Holmes and James A. Cooper. Abraham identified himself as the oldest brother of Samuel. [https://sites.rootsweb.com/~mostodd2/probate/pro201.htm]

This is noteworthy in and of itself even though it is not the main document that pieces together this family. This assertion by Abraham indicates a couple of things. We have determined Samuel was likely too old to be William's son, meaning Abraham was also a son of James. He clearly means eldest "surviving" brother, because we have determined that the elder Benjamin Holmes was the oldest of the listed 12 men, proving Benjamin was deceased by this time. We now have two documents proving relationships between two Holmes men--that is, until we get to additional probate records.

Unlike the two documents cited above, the bulk of Samuel's estate records are not online. I ordered them from the Stoddard County archives, along with the estates of James Holmes and others, to see what clues they might yield. Fortunately, we hit a gold mine.

Abraham states in the probate records that Samuel had insufficient funds for his estate to pay his debts. But as he owned numerous land holdings, those could be sold to collect money to pay off his debts. He secured permission to sell land for that purpose, but in order to accomplish this, he had to secure the permission of all of Samuel's heirs. His heirs were, by default, his siblings and the surviving heirs of his deceased siblings. Most of these heirs were minors and did not live in Stoddard County, so the estate had to sue the absent parties to override the need for their permission to divide and subsequently sell Samuel's land in order to pay his debts.

Note: I don't currently have the patience to transcribe the very difficult-to-read documents, many words of which are illegible and it makes an attempt at a full transcription very confusing with so many missing words. I am going to be focused mostly on the names of the parties rather than the specifics of the legal transactions occurring in these documents. Sections with gaps will be separated by an ellipsis.  

Stoddard County, Missouri
Circuit Court Book D, Pages 710-711

Stoddard County Circuit Court November Term 1871

Absalom Holmes, Abraham Holmes, }
and George W. Holmes, Plaintiffs      } Petition for the Partition of Real Estate
against                                                } 
The heirs of James Holmes, deceased, to wit Samuel Holmes & Absalom Holmes, the unknown heirs of Benjamin Holmes, deceased, the heirs of Jacob Holmes, deceased, to wit William Holmes, Julia Ann Holmes, George W. Holmes, & Caroline Holmes, and Sylvia Lee late Holmes, and the unknown heirs of Milly Wright late Holmes, Defendants

Now on this 9th day of January, 1872...the said plaintiffs and defendants are the legal representatives of the said Samuel Holmes, deceased, and the original parties [illegible], the said Absalom Holmes, Abraham Holmes, George W. Holmes, Benjamin Holmes, Jacob Holmes, James Holmes, Sylvia Lee (late Holmes), and Milly Wright (late Holmes), being brothers and sisters of the said Samuel Holmes, deceased, and are [as] such entitled to the one eighth part of the following real estate hereafter described. That the said James Holmes is deceased, that said Samuel Holmes Junior was his son and entitled to the interest of the deceased father and if further appearing that said interest had been legally transferred to James A. Cooper, to whom the said interest now belongs, that the said Jacob Holmes is dead and left as his legal representatives to wit William, Julia Ann, George W. Junior, and Caroline Holmes, are each entitled to the one fourth of an eighth of said estate, that Sylvia Lee is now dead leaving heirs whose names and places of residence is unknown, that they are entitled to the one eighth part of said real estate, that Milly Wright late Holmes is now dead and left heirs whose names and residence are unknown, but who are entitled to the one eighth part of said real estate, that the said Benjamin Holmes is dead and left heirs whose names and places of residence is unknown but who are entitled to the interest of their deceased parent to wit one eighth part, that said real estate is as follows to wit...

Pages 442-443 of the same Circuit Court book show where Samuel Holmes Junior, son of James, transferred his right to his father's portion of the estate to James A. Cooper. Interestingly, the defendants list a second Absalom Holmes as an additional heir to James, but he is not mentioned again in the full listing of heirs of Samuel's siblings above. And in fact, Samuel Jr.'s attorney states that he was administrator of James's estate and that Samuel Jr. was his only heir--but that was untrue. C. B. [Caleb B.] Crumb was indeed James's estate administrator--but Samuel Jr. was not the only heir. Like Samuel, James died intestate--but documents show he had another son.

In Stoddard County Probate Book C (at least I think it says C--my photocopy halfway cuts off the book it came from) on pages 771-772, on 31 Aug 1868 the court orders the appearance of Samuel M. Holmes, minor heir of James Holmes, deceased, to appear before the court and "show cause, if any he has, why a guardian should not be appointed for him." He would have been about 20 years old, not quite the age of majority. The court then appoints William B. (or P.) Cone of "Absalom M. Holmes, Minor Heir of James Holmes, Deceased".

I can find no further record of Absalom M. Holmes. I can find William Cone in Stoddard County up to 1860, but not after. They either moved from the area, or more likely died. I would assume that Caleb Crumb did not lie about Samuel being the only of James--I believe he meant only "living" heir, implying that between 1868-1872, Absalom M. Holmes died. I have not found any information to the contrary.

But that doesn't mean there weren't sum, um, "fibs" in these estate records. They gave the heirs of James and Jacob. They said the heirs of Benjamin were unknown; I too don't know who these heirs are. I think it's possible that they are the young children residing with Samuel Holmes in the 1830 Census, but I can't prove it. Perhaps the family did not stay in touch with Benjamin's children when their mother presumably remarried. But while it is true that their sisters Sylvia and Milly were deceased by 1872, I don't think it likely at all that their heirs were "unknown" to the surviving Holmes brothers.

Before we move on to that though, let us rejoice! We can now answer several questions about these Holmes families and how they were configured.

Firstly, and perhaps most importantly, this document proves that William Holmes was not the son of James Holmes. His children would also have been Samuel's heirs if he had. So the 15 year age gap here indicates that James was indeed the elder brother of William. If you have James Sr. as the father of William b. 1783 in your tree, it is time to amend your tree to show him as the son of James's father, the eldest William who served in the Revolution.

Secondly, this pieces together the sons of James and William as follows:

Sons of James, b. 1768:
1. Benjamin, born circa 1798
2. Samuel, b. 1802
3. Abraham, b. 1806
4. Absalom, b. 1813
5. George W., b. 1815
6. James, b. 1816
7. Jacob, b. 1819

Sons of William, b. 1783:
1. James, b. 1807
2. Welcome, b. 1814
3. Benjamin, b. 1816
4. William, b. 1823

You'll notice this leaves out the John Holmes who appears in the 1837 tax list of Perry County. I would posit two possible scenarios:

1. John is unrelated to this family. Holmes not being a terribly uncommon surname, he may have just been living in Perry County at that time and not been related to the family.

2. John may in fact be a son of James, but died without heirs prior to Samuel's death, meaning he was not entitled to his estate nor did he leave any heirs entitled to it.

Number 2 is possible only because James's 1820 Census leaves open the possibility of another son. We now know the enumerations of that household apply as follows:

James Holmes - 1820 Census - Perry County, Tennessee
Males under 10 - 4 (Absalom, George, James, Jacob)
Males 10-15 - 2 (Abraham and ???, perhaps this is John)
Males 16-18 - 1 (Benjamin)

So now we know where our various Holmes belong in their respective families. Now we should turn to the two "new" (and by that, I mean previously unknown) family members: Sylvia and Milly Holmes. I found each woman in various family trees, but only a handful, and neither had parents assigned to them. In fact, Sylvia's maiden name being Holmes was known because of various vital records of her children, but Milly's maiden name was unknown among her descendants until now according to all the family trees I could find. The information I will show here will indicate, as I stated above, that the Holmes brothers were indeed aware of the names and probably the places of residence for their respective sisters, but perhaps in order to avoid further hassle and litigation they decided to feign ignorance of their nieces and nephews. I don't think we'll ever know for sure.

I also want to point out two more interesting tidbits from the estate records of Samuel Holmes. One will tie in directly with the identity of one of his sisters.

In July, 1869 a "controversy" arose concerning the debts of a William S. Welborn to Samuel's estate. Among the witnesses called to try and settle the matter was a Stephen Holmes. I was previously unaware of this Stephen, but I found him in the 1870 Census for Stoddard County. He was born in 1843 in Tennessee, and he was a black man, or possibly mixed. I don't know if he was related to our family or not, but his name stood out to me when combing Samuel's estate records.

Secondly, in 1866, an inventory was submitted to the court listing all of the debts owed to Samuel's estate. One of those enumerated debts was as follows:

1 quit claim due from Niel W. Wright for the West Half of NW 1/4 & SE 1/4 of NW 1/4 of Section 15 in Township N 25, Range 11 E

This indicates that Niel W. Wright was a resident of Stoddard County, at least around 1866. Oh, and who are Niel's parents? I'm glad you asked. According to the 1850 Census in Crittenden County, Kentucky, they are Thomas and Mildred Wright. And according to the death certificates of multiple children of their's, what was their mother's name? Why, Millie Holmes, of course. And not-so-coincidentally, in the 1830 Census of Perry County, Tennessee, who was enumerated two spaces away from the adjacent households of Samuel and Abraham Holmes? Why, Thomas Wright, of course.

Mildred "Millie/Milly" Holmes appears to have married Thomas Wright about 1826-1827, according to the age of their eldest daughter. After 1830, they are found in Bourbon County, Kentucky in 1840, and in Crittenden County after that. Mildred J. Wright Holmes is buried at the Boyd Cemetery near Sheridan, Kentucky. She was born 14 Jul 1811 and died 15 Feb 1868, according to her headstone. So she was in fact deceased by the time of the partitioning of Samuel Holmes's real estate. But if her son Niel was living in Stoddard County in the 1860s, then Samuel was clearly aware of his nephews name and residence and would therefore certainly know the names and residences of Niel's siblings. And if that is the case, his brothers would likely know as well. Supporting that is the fact that Niel (or Neal) enlisted to serve in the 16th Missouri Infantry (Confederate) out of Newton County, Missouri, also known as the county of residence for Absalom Holmes during the Civil War.

Again, I can't speak to why Absalom, Abraham, and George pretended to not know the names and residences of their nieces and nephews, but it seems pretty clear they did in fact know them.

Further, the facts indicate the brothers were also aware of their Lee nieces and nephews, even if they claimed not to be.

As mentioned above, in the 1850 Census you'll find enumerated the following households all in Campbell Township, Searcy, Arkansas:

William Holmes Jr., son of William and brother of James
George W. Holmes, son of James
Jacob L. Holmes, son of James
William Holmes III, son of William
Abraham Holmes, son of James

Various other Holmeses are either in Hartsugg Township, Van Buren County, Arkansas, right next to the Searcy County border, or other parts of Searcy County--other than Samuel and his brother James, who are still in Wayne County, TN at this time.

But also in Campbell Township, Searcy, Arkansas, you'll find the household of...

Sylvia Lee, born about 1812 in TN
Wyatt Lee, born about 1834 in TN
Sarah Lee, born about 1838 in TN
James Lee, born about 1840 in TN
Amanda Lee, born about 1845 in MO

The chances of this being anyone other than Slyvia Holmes Lee seem slim. But for better assurance, you'll find that also in Campbell, Searcy, Arkansas are the households of Gashum Lee and his apparent father, Joseph. Gashum was born in Tennessee, and Joseph in South Caronlina. This apparently same Joseph and his apparent brother, also named Gashum, can be found in the 1820 Census in...you guessed it, Perry County, Tennessee.

The family then went to Wayne County, where in 1840 Joseph Lee, represented by his "lawful attorney Gashum Lee", deeded land to Samuel Denton of Perry County [https://www.genealogy.com/forum/surnames/topics/lee/15179/]. This indicates a familiarity with the Denton family, who also ended up in and around Campbell, Searcy, Arkansas. Carmen Baxter, the Lee family researcher that shared that information, also references an Abel Lee as a relative and likely brother of the elder Gashum Lee. Abel and Gashum were likely brothers of Joseph, and they were apparently in Lincoln County, Tennessee prior to eventually coming to Perry. And in later years, a daughter of Sylvia Lee would claim her father's name was Abel Lee. I am assuming this was another son of Joseph, but I cannot find any records of Abel Lee, so I cannot be sure. For now, I list Sylvia's husband as as unknown Lee, possibly Abel Lee.

I believe that Sylvia's husband, whatever his name, died in or about 1850 because it would appear she actually had a 5th (or 6th or more) child by him. If Sylvia had children older than Wyatt, we don't have documentation of them. However, I think it highly likely that Ambrose Lee is also their son. Ambrose is also in Campbell, Searcy, Arkansas in 1850, living in a Baker household and apparently working as their farmhand. He was born about 1831. He is later found in Coryell County, Texas and is buried in nearby Bell County, Texas. McLennan County also borders these counties.

This area of Texas is the same area where Sylvia's confirmed children ended up. They are living in Bell County in the late 1860s, and Sarah Lee Crouch can be found in McLennan County in 1870. James Lee marries in Bell County in 1868, though he is in Dallas by 1870. Wyatt is also documented as living in Bell County in the late 1860s, but is in Dallas County by 1870. I think it would be a big coincidence for Ambrose to go from Searcy County, Arkansas to the Bell County, Texas region without connection to these other Lees. They are almost certainly cousins at least, but I think Ambrose is most likely a son of Sylvia.

Sylvia is buried in the Rawlins Cemetery near Lancaster, Dallas County, Texas. Her headstone states she died 20 Apr 1867. The 1850 Census indicates she was born about 1812 in Tennessee; she is absent from the 1860 Census. This would mean that in 1820, 9 year old Mildred was enumerated in the 10-15 year old column, and Sylvia in the under 10 column of James Holmes's household. It is unknown who the 10-14 year old in James's 1830 household would be, but if Ambrose is Sylvia's son and was born about 1831 (and his headstone says he was born about 1824--but all his Census records from 1850-1880 indicate 1830-1831) then she was likely married by that point. The 10-14 year old was not enumerated in James's 1820 household, so she was likely not his daughter but some other relation.

Sylvia Lee dying in 1867 aligns with Samuel Holmes's estate stating she was deceased in 1872. Again, since she lived in the same township with George and Abraham Holmes in 1850, we know they were aware of their nieces' and nephews' names, even if they perhaps did not know their residences in 1872. I want to point out some additional information I found when researching Sylvia's family.

None of her children have death certificates as best I can ascertain, but as I mentioned, I do believe she had a 5th (or 6th if you agree that Ambrose is likely her son) child. A Cynthia Louisa Lee married a James Dial/Dyle on 3 Feb 1868 in Coryell County, TX (Ambrose was already living in Coryell at this time, by the way). She is not located in the 1870 Census. She was remarried to a Benjamin F. Haney circa 1873. She was widowed again and remarried to William J. Renfro(w) on 6 Sep 1877 in Johnson County, TX. By 1880, she is in Eastland County, TX, and by 1900 in Chickasaw Nation, near Woodville (now New Woodville) five miles southeast of Kingston in Marshall County, Oklahoma.

It may not have registered that Cynthia was a part of this family were it not for an 1868 incident. The Ku Klux Klan, or "The Mob", threatened and attacked several members of her family. Her sister Sarah had married Benjamin Crouch by this time, and Mr. Crouch was one of the main victimized parties reporting to the incident to Lt. D. F. Stiles of the U. S. Army. He states that he, his wife, and "Mrs. Dial, a widow" fled Bell County for McLennan County due to the KKK's threats, and that his wife's brothers, "the Lee brothers", were on the run from them. This report proves Cynthia Lee Dial's association with Sarah Lee Crouch and indicates she is their sister. It is theoretically possible she is a cousin or other relation, but sister seems most likely.

The incident made national news and can be read in its entirety in the 15 Jul 1868 edition of the Sacramento Daily Union (Sacramento, CA) or the 8 Jul 1868 edition of the Semi-Weekly Wisconsin (Milwaukee, WI), and numerous other papers in July, 1868.

In part, the report states:

Ku-Klux Klan In Texas - Official Report of Lieutenant D. F. Stiles, United States Army.

An abstract of the report of the officer directed by Major General Reynolds, commanding, to investigate and report In regard to the alleged outrages of the Ku Klux Klan in Texas. Is as follows : On the 20th of May I proceeded to Waco, McLennan county, and there found Benjamin Crouch, Mrs. Crouch, his wife, and Mrs. Dial, a widow. Crouch informed me, under oath, that on or about the night of April 15, 1868, the mob— or the Ku-Klux, as they are called In Bell county came into his house and forced bis wife to open the door. Three men— William Eritt, William Pruitt and Joseph Webb — searched the premises. They presented their pistols in Crouch's face and threatened to shoot him if he ever fed or harbored any of his friends- many of whom were lying out in fear of the mob.

After ordering Crouch to leave the county, they left the house and joined a band of a dozen men who waited outside. Fearing violence. Crouch left his home and moved to McLennan county. He afterward returned to his place for the purpose of getting his stock and some cotton he bad left in his flight, but could find nothing. He was informed that the property was taken possession of by the mob. The Lee brothers — brothers-in-law of Crouch were lying out at the time, and thus escaped. They afterward fled to Arkansas. Mrs. Dial accompanied the Lieutenant as far as Galesville in search of her younger brother, who had been reported killed. 

Though further in the report, the officer concludes that at least one of the brothers must have been killed due to the discovery of his pistol and horse in possession of KKK associates, the 1870 Census proves both James and Wyatt survived and fled to Dallas County.

Descendants of Cynthia Louisa Lee Dial Haney Renfro have combined her with Amanda Lee, daughter of Sylvia Holmes Lee. It is not known what became of Amanda. But in the 1880 and 1900 Censuses, she reports having been born in Missouri in 1850-1851, making her several years younger than Amanda. However, in her tribal enrollment (see below) she claims to have been born closer to 1844-1845, but based on the false information she gave in her application, she may well not have been truthful about her age as well.

Rather than assuming her name was Cynthia Louisa Amanda or some other combination of these names, it is more likely that Sylvia was pregnant when she was widowed and had Cynthia after the 1850 Census. She must have gone to Missouri for whatever to have her child, perhaps even Stoddard County if her brothers had already arrived there. It makes far more sense for Cynthia and Amanda to be two different people than one in the same, but hey, it's possible.

In her later years, I believe Cynthia either lost her marbles a bit or made a valiant attempt to defraud the United States government and its indigenous people. In 1900, Cynthia decided to enumerate herself as a Native American and apply for tribal citizenship in the Choctaw Nation. She was not alone; a number of destitute white people tried to make a case for unclear (and usually non-existent) Native American heritage in order to reap the rewards of free land that came along with it. There are still people attempting this same scam today, unfortunately.

In her application, she now gives her age in 1900 as 55 (even though she said was 49 a couple months previous for the Census). She claimed that her mother was 1/4 Choctaw. She said he mother "lived in the far back nation and in Tennessee about '41, 2, and 3; she lived in Mississippi; my mother never lived here." She claimed to have come to the Choctaw Nation (in modern-day Oklahoma) when she was small, about 1850, stayed there a few years and then went to Arkansas. She said that after 10 years there, they came back to "the territory" for four years, and then lived in Texas from 1861-1883, when she says she came back to IT, and went back and forth between IT and Texas more times.

Her enrollment was refused, and she tried again, answering more questions. She says now she was born in February, 1844. Here are some of the questions she was asked and answers she tendered.

Q. Are you a Choctaw?
A. I was raised and taught that.
Q. Do you claim Choctaw by blood?
A. Yes sir, by blood.
Q. What is the name of your father?
A. Abel Lee.
Q. Was he an Indian?
A. No sir.
Q. What is your mother's name?
A. Cynthia Lee. 
Q. Is she living?
A. No sir.
Q. Was she an Indian?
A. Yes sir.
Q. How much Indian blood did she claim to have?
A. She called herself one quarter.
Q. And how much Indian blood do you claim?
A. One eighth.
Q. Was your mother's name ever on any of the Choctaw tribal rolls?
A. No sir.
Q. Is your name on any of the Choctaw tribal rolls?
A. In what county and district did your mother belong?
Q. I can't tell you.

And it goes on like that, with more questions she can't answer and her providing no proof of her claims. She was unable to provide any witnesses to corroborate her claims either. She was seeking enrollment for herself, a child, and a grandchild. As I said, I believe she was simply looking to acquire the federal benefits of tribal membership. Up until 1900, every record she appeared in listed her as a white person, and same with all of her siblings, nieces, nephews, and maternal first cousins, uncles, and aunt. She there is not one shred of evidence that there was Native heritage in the Holmes family. Barring a grand conspiracy where literally dozens if not hundreds of Census takers, county and state officials, medical and religious professionals, and military personnel ALL LIED and said that these Native Americans were white in what was notoriously one of the most racially divided centuries in the history of the world...then no, the Holmes family and their kin were not Native. See Census Card number 252 in the Choctaw Enrollment category of the Native American Applications for Enrollment in the Five Civilized Tribes, 1898-1914 collection on Ancestry or Family Search for the complete application.

The primary purpose of this post was to piece together the families of James and William Holmes. Now that that has been accomplished, I want to add some supplemental information--but from here on out, we are merely dealing with some of my ideas and theories. Almost none of what I am about to share can currently be satisfactorily proven, but they are theories I am trying to work out. And perhaps someone else that can answer these questions or provide necessary supplemental information will come across this blog and be able to fill in some blanks for me, which would be awesome.

Firstly, I want to mention two men that I have considered could be connected to our brothers James and William Holmes. The first is an Isaac Holmes. He was born about 1778 in South Carolina according to the 1850 Census in Coffee County, Tennessee. He ended up there by way of Warren and Bedford counties. I don't know anything about his heritage, but he came to my attention because one of his daughters ended up in Stoddard County, Missouri like James's sons Samuel, James, and Abraham. Keziah Holmes, wife of William Smith, was in Stoddard County by the 1870 Census, and reportedly died there in 1887. I found it interesting that a Tennessee-native Holmes with a South Carolina-native father ended up in Stoddard County, but I cannot otherwise connect Isaac with James or William.

I've also been intrigued by a Robert Holmes b. 1793 in South Carolina. He can be found in Carroll and Bedford counties. Again, I have found no definitive connections, but I consider him a "person of interest" and have been on the look out for his descendants among my Holmes DNA matches.

Lastly, I want to discuss the Denton and Shipman families. They were two other early Perry and Wayne county families that intermarried with each other, and had branches that came to Searcy County, Arkansas when the Holmeses did. At least two Denton sisters are documented as marrying Holmes brothers--Mary Denton and Wincey Denton, daughters of Benjamin, married James and Benjamin Holmes, respectively, sons of William Holmes. Benjamin Denton's wife is supposed to be Nancy Shipman. This was likely deduced because one of their sons was named Shipman Denton. [Source: https://www.genealogy.com/forum/surnames/topics/denton/2637/] I think it's also worth noting that one of the signers of the 1819 petition to form Perry County was Denton Shipman (yes, you read that right--one was Shipman Denton and one was Denton Shipman).

A Christopher Denton and his apparent brothers Absalom, John, and James all came to Searcy and Van Buren counties from Perry County. Their father was not Benjamin; if they were all indeed brothers, then only Abraham Denton had enough sons in his household in the 1820 Census in Perry County to accommodate all of them. Family history dictates that Christopher's wife Elizabeth was a Holmes. There is nothing to support this other than anecdotal evidence and a Denton reseracher's interpretation of the following court records.

In 1834, Christopher and his brother James were tried for petit larceny. James was convicted and Chris was acquitted. During the proceedings, it was noted that James Holmes Sr. and William Holmes were excused from the jury for being relatives of Denton by marriage. People have interpreted that to mean that Christopher's wife was a Holmes. I have interpreted that to mean James and William married Denton sisters. Elizabeth's Census records from 1850-1880 put her born about 1820, and maybe as late as 1826 according to one year. But William does not have a 5-9 year old daughter in 1830, only one under 5. And he has a 10-14 year old daughter in 1840, presumably the same girl. Could she be Elizabeth and she really was born closer to 1826 than 1820? It is possible, but I have not seen any reason to believe that other than how folks interpreted the jury dismissals of James and William Holmes.

Another woman from Searcy County is attached as a daughter of William--a Malinda Adeline, wife of Richard Watts. She is in Searcy County in 1850, and Van Buren County in 1860, but she was born in 1820 according to these records and as already established, there is no fitting enumeration for this daughter in William's households.

If you look at the names of James Holmes's sons, it is easy to see why it makes more sense to interpret his jury dismissal as his being married to a Denton himself. Absalom, Abraham, Samuel, James, and Benjamin Denton all signed the 1819 petition to form Perry County. And then James happens to name sons Absalom, Abraham, Samuel, James, and Benjamin. Coincidence? Probably not. Numerous DNA matches between Holmes descendants and Denton descendants further implies the connection. And because William was also dismissed from the jury, I believe his wife was another Denton sister. Their wives were most likely sisters of Christopher Denton, making him their nephew. Again, I can't prove this with documentation, but the evidence strongly indicates this to be the case.

Besides the connection the mutual connection to the Dentons, the reason the Shipmans intrigue me is because, well, I am a Shipman as well. This Holmes family is on my mother's side, but on my father's side I descend from this same Shipman family that married in with the Dentons. The Jacob Shipman of Perry County was said to have been married to a Nancy Denton. My ancestor was another Jacob Shipman, a cousin of this Jacob. Mine lived in Wayne County and also made the trip to Searcy County, where he died after 1851.

The Shipman and Denton ancestries have a lot of holes and question marks in them; it is possible there is more overlap than we know. I have considered that my parents might both descend from the Dentons one way or another. It would not be the first time; my parents are distant cousins through the Napier and Todd families, and my mother's parents are cousins through the Moon family. I have other instances where my grandparents' families intermarry with one another. So really, anything possible when it comes to the genealogies of those of us with early American colonial ancestry, especially Southern colonials.

I hope this information will be helpful to Holmes descendants and researchers. If you have any questions or supplemental information, please feel free to e-mail me. 

Saturday, January 19, 2019

Mary Snellgrove Rorie & Her Complicated Parentage

Say this with me slowly:

Don't
Trust
Ancestry
Trees

I can't emphasize this point enough. You just can't trust other people's trees on Ancestry or Rootsweb or even personal genealogy sites. Certainly don't trust FamilySearch trees and Wiki Tree and similar sites, where anyone can alter the trees willy-nilly. Can they be a good jumping off point? Absolutely. But you have to verify everything you find, every single morsel of information has to be proven with a credible source or you could really be setting yourself up for trouble.

NOT doing this is what landed us in the pickle we have today: sorting out the parentage (and their related families) of Mary Snellgrove, wife of Absalom Josiah "Jody" Rorie, my 4th great grandparents whose stories begin in Tennessee and end in Searcy, Stone, and Baxter counties in Arkansas. And guess what? Some of the problems are MY fault.

Mary Snellgrove's maiden name seemed questionable at best, and her parentage was completely unknown when I started heavily researching my Rorie lineage about ten years ago. My being a lover of "original genealogy" (doing research on families that have not already been pieced together by others in years past), I took it upon myself to figure exactly where and from whom Mary came. And I did! I succeeded and I was right...but I also made mistakes.

The main two mistakes I made were: 1) combining two different men to "make" Mary's father, and 2) allowing my research on my PRIVATE Ancestry tree to be absorbed by the PUBLIC trees of cousins I invited to view my tree, which then allowed others to absorb the information, and away it went!

I started making my tree private several years ago for two primary reasons:

A) I found that my tree was a constant work in progress (like most genealogists' trees) and so I was regularly adding and subtracting information and notes. Recognizing that sometimes information I added or theories I put in my tree to see how they "fit" could be interpreted by amateur genealogists as reliable information, I decided to make my tree private so my unverified ideas and theories, or information I got WRONG, would not be absorbed by others, and then it would not be my fault when the "bad" information spread around the internet like HPV.

B) I grew tired of finding my "original" research being absorbed into others' trees, right or wrong, and especially when people didn't just "save" an image I uploaded to their tree but actually downloaded it and re-uploaded it to their tree so it looked like they were the original contributors.

Alas, despite my efforts, some of my "working" or "in progress" information did end up slipping through the cracks when I invited trusted cousins to view my private tree. They then took my information and added it to their public trees, and so the wildfire had begun.

Now it is time to try to right one of these wrongs as best I can. I can't go and change the incorrect trees on Ancestry. And no doubt future lazy genealogists will continue absorbing the bad information into their trees because they don't VERIFY it. But if you found this page in the course of researching your family or our mutual families, you probably care enough to verify the information that is "out there", so this clarification is for YOU. It will let you see why I have come to the conclusions I have and why much of what is "out there" is wrong. So because YOU tried to VERIFY what you found online, your tree will be MORE correct than those that did not. Note that I am not saying "perfect" or "100% accurate" because no one has one of those, but your tree will at least be closer to "passing grade" than "big fat F".

The other purpose of this blog is to control the dialogue on the family to an extent. It is easy to allow assumptions and misconceptions to run rampant on the internet when doing genealogy. Those with well-sourced Ancestry trees or that control Find A Grave memorials control the dialogue surrounding certain figures and the information associated with them to the extent that those are oft-cited resources for casual genealogists building their trees. The other way to take a hold of the information being disseminated is to use genealogy blogs like this to share articles that dispel rumors and bad information and compile all the good and useful information into a single essay. This allows for easier and more reasonable conclusions than those reached by people basing their trees almost exclusively on the research of others.

So we'll start from Mary and work our way backward, and I will be sure to note my own previous errors and my THEORIES as THEORIES, while also dispelling some of the incorrect research of others who have shared information on these families.

Mary was the wife of Absalom Josiah Rorie, who also went by the nickname "Jody". She is buried at Table Rock Cemetery near Big Flat, Arkansas. Her original headstone states she was born 30 Jun 1839 (stone is broken right where her DOB is, so this date comes from older cemetery surveys and stone rubbings) and died 25 Jun 1914. The birthdate seems to reflect her Census records, which place her year of birth between 1838-1840 and her month of birth in Jun. The death date is questionable because of an obituary for her which would place her date of death as 2 Jul 1914.


My own picture of Mary's stone taken in 2017.


My picture zoomed in. You'll see where the stone is broken along her DOB and where her date of death says 25 Jun 1914, rather than the 26th. The 26th is what her Find A Grave Memorial and most Ancestry trees say, but that is a pretty clear "5" rather than "6" to me. 


We have to mention the "other" stone. A well-meaning cousin purchased new stones for various Rorie family members buried Table Rock a number of years ago. Not all of them were correct or placed in the right spots. This error was particularly egregious; it should have been 1839-1914, but instead was made to say 1914-1939, implying she was born when her youngest child was in their mid-30s. Pay no mind to this stone. 


Courtesy of Newspapers.com. The 10 Jul 1914 edition of The Baxter Bulletin (Mountain Home, Arkansas), page 4. If this is to be believed, Mary's actual date of death was 2 Jul 1914. Since it's a week's difference, it is possible this article just ran a week late, but it's hard to say. The family was not well-off, per Absalom's Federal Pension records, so it is possible these stones were not made until after his death in 1916 or even later, by which time surviving kin may have gotten the date wrong. 


Photo of Absalom Josiah "Jody" Rorie and wife, Mary. I have already shared this before so I have no issue sharing it again. I have a second (very poor quality) photo of this pair, and a third photo with just Mary (also not the best quality, but at least as good as this one). I have stopped sharing many of my "finds" on my blog because people like to copy them and add them to Ancestry and Find A Grave and personal genealogy websites without crediting me as the person that provided the digital image, or crediting the person who provided the original. This particular photo comes courtesy of my cousin A. J. Rorie, son of Allie F. Rorie. If someone would like me to send them the other pictures I have, I will gladly respond to a polite request with a promise to credit the sources of the photos. 

So in working out Mary's parentage, I needed to start with what was definitively known about Mary, and that was all: first name, husband, place of burial, likely dates of birth and death. The names of her children were given in Census records, which also consistently reported her state of birth as Tennessee. Her oldest known child was born in 1857, and her youngest known child was born in 1882. We can presume based on her birth in 1839 and her eldest child being born in 1857 that she likely married Jody around 1855-1856 when she would have been 16-17 years old. Despite what some online trees would have you believed, marriages at age 15 and younger at this time were NOT commonplace.

Many places give her a middle name "Elizabeth". There is no proof of this name whatsoever. No record in Mary's lifetime even gives her the middle initial "E", much less a full maiden name. Someone at some point decided she MUST have had a middle name and since "Elizabeth" was such a common name and "Mary Sarah" just doesn't have the same ring to it, they decided her middle name HAD TO BE "Elizabeth". No proof, just nonsense.


Facepalm photo courtesy of Murray's Review of Medical Journalism (https://murraysreview.com). Get ready. There are going to be a lot of facepalms in this post. 

Don't give Mary a middle name. If she had one, records would bear that out and they don't.

Some trees did not have a maiden name for Mary. Most had the name Snellgrove/Snelgrove or a close variation to that. So it was time to figure out if that was true.

In the Rorie lineage, it was known that the Rories came from Hardin County, Tennessee. Unfortunately, due to courthouse fires in 1859, 1864, and 1949 (source: https://www.familysearch.org/wiki/en/Hardin_County,_Tennessee_Genealogy#Record_Loss), marriage records prior to 1863 in this county have been lost. But since their oldest son was born in Arkansas, it was possible they were married in Arkansas instead of Tennessee. In 1860, they are in  Big Flat, Arkansas, which at the time was in Searcy County. Unfortunately, Searcy County was also subject to courthouse fires in 1864, 1877, and 1885, so the earliest marriage records from there start in 1881. (Source: https://www.familysearch.org/wiki/en/Searcy_County,_Arkansas_Genealogy#Record_Loss)

In 1873, Baxter County was formed from parts of four counties, including Searcy, which led to the Big Flat area becoming split between Searcy and Baxter counties. This is worth mentioning because other than a stint Stone county, this family primarily lived in and around Baxter County, and often in places that used to be Searcy County, like Big Flat.

So no marriage record for this pair can be located in any surviving Tennessee or Arkansas statewide marriage records. Where does that leave us when it comes to determining Mary's lineage? Well, first we quash an old family myth.

It is NOT a myth that among Mary's and Jody's children were three sons that were either born blind, or ended up blind. James Albert "Buddy", John Absalom, and Henry Newton Rorie were blind.


Buddy, John, and Henry, known as the "Blind Rorie Brothers", made brooms.

It is also worth noting:

- In 1870, Buddy is listed as blind but John and Henry are not.

- In 1880, all three are listed as blind, as is a fourth brother: Hezekiah. Later census records show he was not blind, but it's interesting that he was marked as such when he was young. Perhaps he just had very poor vision.

- A fifth son, Hugh Alec, was hump-backed, but it is not clear if he was this was at birth or became that way due to an accident or condition.

The most believable version of how the brothers became blind is that they became so in an unfortunate accident as youths. Since Buddy was already listed as blind before Henry and John though, it is possible genetics played a role and that Henry and John succumbed to blindness after an accident possibly because of a genetic predisposition or other genetic condition. Whatever the genetic component, it is believed by many in the family that this was due to Mary and Jody being related and that these "defects" were due to incestual relations or "inbreeding".

There is absolutely no merit to this theory, which will be clear once we explore Mary's origins. But it needs to be mentioned since apparently some have barked up Jody's family tree in an effort to find Mary in it, but since they aren't related, she's not in Jody's tree other than as his wife. As my cousin Kenneth Rorie put it: "I have my doubts about the incest, although I don't know for sure.  It seems (even though I'm a Rorie) that the Rorie family just wanted to shift it to the Snelgrove side.  Back in those days, handicaps were viewed differently than they are today, as you know.  Often family would hide children they considered defective from others to see and rarely took them out in public.  It was also common to blame an early injury of some kind for any sort of mental handicap."

An additional rumor about why the boys succumbed to blindness was that Jody contracted syphilis in the Civil War and it ended up spreading to his sons. This is complete nonsense since I have more than 100 pages of Federal Pension files on Jody that include extensive medical records of any and all ailments Jody was experiencing late in life.

There was no penicillin in those days, so if he contracted it, he would have had it for life. His medical records cover all the issues he was experiencing and EMPHASIZED conditions incurred due to his Civil War service. Not one mention is made of his having contracted syphilis or any similar disease. It is an insult to his memory to further propagate this lie. If it had any standing in documentation, like his medical records which I have combed through thoroughly, I would not take issue with it. People were people, even our ancestors, and the best among us can make mistakes. But there is no proof whatsoever of this myth, so it should be put to rest.

Since the "incestuous relationship" rumors were prominent in this family's lore, I scoured Absalom's relatively well-documented Rorie and Meador family trees for where Mary could fit it and did not find her. So it was time to see if there was any stock to the family history that her maiden name was Snelgrove/Snellgrove.

Hezekiah's death certificate (Texas) gives his mother's maiden name as Snellgrace. Hugh's death certificate (Arkansas) gives it as Snellgross. Thomas's (California) says Snellgro. So these would lend credence to the genealogies that showed Mary's maiden name as Snellgrove.

I then wanted to find any other Snellgrove family members from our area around Searcy/Baxter counties, especially those with ties to Tennessee. Since we first find Mary in the 1860 Census in Big Flat, Searcy, Arkansas, it made sense to start there. The 1860 Census in Searcy County gave me two Snellgrove families with apparent Tennessee ties: G. Snelgrove (born 1801 in South Carolina) and Henry Snellgrove (born 1835 in Tennessee). G. Snelgrove's wife Rebecca (b. 1812) was born in Tennessee, as were several other members of his household from the Satterfield family, indicating Tennessee ties. G. Snellgrove would be old enough to be Mary's father, and Henry's too if he were Mary's sibling.

Deeper digging provided G. Snellgrove's first name: Gasaway. A Gasaway Snellgrove was on a member list of the Arkansas Peace Society, also called they "Yellar Rag Boys", a group based in the Searcy County area. This group was comprised of loyalists to the Union formed after Arkansas seceded and joined the Confederacy. Several members of the Satterfield were also members, including some residing in G. Snelgrove's 1860 household. A membership list and organization info can be found here: http://www.couchgenweb.com/civilwar/peacelst.htm

This group was betrayed and its members rounded up. From Yellar Rag Boys: The Arkansas Peace Society of 1861 And Other Events in Northwest Arkansas - 1861-1865 by Luther E. Warren (1992), page 7, a biographical sketch of noted society member Paris G. Strickland is recorded. The sketch was originally published on page 133 of Loyalty on the Frontier by Albert Webb Bishop (1863):

"Of the 'Peace Organization Society' he was a member, and labored industriously to disseminate its views, dominant among which was the assertion of the right of communities to combine together for the mutual protection of life and property. The society had its ramifications, especially in Conway, Marion, Pope, Searcy and Van Buren Counties, and members knew each other in the customary manner of secret associations. Although seeking tranquility amidst disturbance of the most alarming character, the order, if it may be so termed, was thoroughly loyal; and in a State and at a time, where and when armed opposition to the rebel powers would have been fruitless of good result, was quietly molding a public sentiment that in time would have been able to counteract the rebellious proclivities of the locality, had it not early been betrayed.

One John Holmes, of Van Buren County, and a Mr. Garrison, are entitled to this miserable distinction, and should they now be living can lay claim to an amount of misery and destitution altogether beyond their feeble power of atonement. Through their instrumentality, the names of a large number of men belonging to the order were reported to the State Militia, and the order itself was effectually broken up."

I should note that while John Holmes possesses the miserable distinction of having betrayed this group, I regrettably share that unfortunate distinction to a lesser extent due to that fact that Holmes was my relative. The Van Buren County Holmeses are my mother's kin; the Snellgrove/Rorie families were my father's. John W. Holmes of Van Buren County was the son of Benjamin Holmes, a 1st cousin of my 4th great grandfather Absalom Holmes, who lived in and near Van Buren County for several years. I do not know what became of John; he disappears from record after the 1860 Census and his betrayal of the society. Despite his being my kinsman, I rather hope his comeuppance was swift and violent.

Interesting that 125 years after my mother's kin betrayed my father's kin in Arkansas that they would marry in Tulsa, Oklahoma. It's a small world out there.

After the society was betrayed, all the outed members were chained together to form a "chain gang" and forced to march to Little Rock. There they were given a choice: be conscripted into the Confederate army, or go to jail. Most selected the former option, including Gasaway Snellgrove, who at age 50 according to his service record, enlisted in the 18th Arkansas Infantry (Arkansas). This age of 50 in December, 1861 would indicate he was born closer to 1810-1811 rather than 1801. Based on later records, I think this date more likely.


Courtesy of Fold3.com.

He was not the only enrollee of advanced age due to the conscription of Peace Society members; John R. Satterfield (age 60) and Nathaniel Satterfield (age 45) were also among the conscripts. Nathaniel would go on to volunteer to continue fighting in the war but the Union when he enrolled in the 3rd Arkansas Cavalry. It is not clear whether or not Gasaway or John returned home from the war. This Civil War service record is the last record I have found of Gasaway, and John's is the last record I have located for him as well. John is even absent from the 1860 Census, so if not for his service records he would be believed deceased, especially since 3 of his 4 youngest children were being raised by his brother in 1860.

The aforementioned Henry Snellgrove also served in the Civil War, but as a Confederate volunteer. This illustrates a fact all Civil War researchers are aware of: these conflicts divided families. Whatever the relationship between Gasaway and Henry, and they almost certainly were related since there was only ONE Snellgrove family in the state of Tennessee from 1820-1840, they were on opposite sides. Gasaway was a Loyalist who was forced into Confederate service and likely died there. Henry was a Confederate volunteer, as was Mary's husband Jody. He would later be forced the other way--he would be conscripted into the Union army later in the war. But by and large, the Rories were Confederates by choice and only begrudging members of the Union Army.

When searching for more Snellgroves with ties to the area, I found two more.

1. Martha, born 1838 in Tennessee, wife of Joseph Ward. She was in Searcy County in 1860 in Locust Grove, very near Henry Snellgrove. Her son Josiah Ward's 1945 Arkansas death certificate gives his mother's maiden name as "Snellgrose", which may be mis-transcribed doctor's handwriting and say "Snellgrove".

2. Rachel, born 1840 in Tennessee, wife of Arthur Rankin Sisk. At least two of her children's death records give their mother's maiden name as "Snellgrove" or a similar variation. She is near Mary in 1860 in Big Flat, still in Big Flat in 1870, and then in Locust Grove in 1880.

So we have potentially four Snellgrove siblings and possibly their father all in Searcy County in 1860. The four are five years apart in age and all share the same birthplace, so it seems to plausible but more research is needed. Collectively, I will refer to this cluster as the Searcy County Snellgroves.

A closer examination of Mary Rorie's census records showed an error in Ancestry.com's record transcription in 1870. If one looks at the summary of her household on Ancestry, it would show Josiah, Mary, and their children. If you look at the actual image, however, you find an additional household member.


1870 Census - Big Flat, Searcy, Arkansas - Slide 4 of 12. Courtesy of Ancestry.com.

You can see that the census-taker started to enumerate Rebecca Satterfield in her own household, crossed it out, and started the next household with that number. That means Rebecca was living in the Rorie household. She was born in 1812 in Tennessee. She could be a relative, or she could be a non-relative. But when we find her again in 1880, the pieces start to come together.


1880 Census - Locust Grove, Stone, Arkansas - Slide 15 of 18. Courtesy of Ancestry.com.

Here is Rebecca Satterfield, again born 1812 in Tennessee, this time living with Martha Ward and listed as her mother. This is the same Martha Ward whose son Josiah's (also listed in this household) death certificate says his mother was a Snellgrove. So if Mary Rorie's kids say she was a Snellgrove, and Martha Ward's son says she was a Snellgrove, and Rebecca Satterfield lived with both of these women and in 1880 is listed as Martha's mother, that would indicate that Mary and Martha are indeed siblings. It would further indicate that before her married name was Satterfield, Rebecca was married to a Snellgrove.

Here is where things start to get complicated, and where I admit to having originally let my own assumptions get the better of me and went on add information into my tree that later proved to be incorrect. Before I realized my error, the information had been absorbed into public trees and then absorbed by other armchair-genealogists. I can do nothing about that now, but I can try to fix it the only way I can--through this blog. TO BE FAIR, I definitely had a disclaimer as a note to myself that the name of Mary's father was tentative, but those notes did not carry over when the basic information was absorbed by others' trees.

So back to Gasaway Snellgrove. Very conveniently, in the 1860 Census, he happened to have a wife named...Rebecca who was born...about 1812 in Tennessee.


1860 Census - Campbell, Searcy, Arkansas - Slide 5 of 11. Courtesy of Ancestry.com. The barely-legible first half of the household of N. [Nathaniel] Satterfield. 


1860 Census - Campbell, Searcy, Arkansas - Slide 5 of 11. Courtesy of Ancestry.com. The second half of the household of N. Satterfield, including G. and Rebecca Snellgrove. 

My assumption was that Gasaway died in the Civil War or before 1870 and Rebecca remarried to one of the Satterfield family, with whom she is living in 1860, and then may have been widowed a second time by this unknown Satterfield. I even considered John R. who would have been the closest potentially-single Satterfield to her age. Perhaps Gasaway died, John returned home, married Rebecca, and then died himself. I couldn't prove it but it wasn't an implausible theory.

You can see where I'm going with this. It all seemed to fit so perfectly. Gasaway and Rebecca had to be the parents of my Snellgrove sisters who may have had an additional brother (Henry) and sister (Rebecca). BUT there was also another interesting household that I could not entirely satisfactorily explain away.


1860 Census - Big Flat, Searcy, Arkansas - Slide 5 of 13. Courtesy of Ancestry.com. The household of Peter M. Sutterfield, followed by the households of James A. Rorie and Josiah A. Rorie.

There actually was a Rebecca Satterfield born 1812 in Tennessee in Searcy County already. And she lived two households from Josiah and Mary. So who was Mary's mother? Rebecca Snellgrove or Rebecca Satterfield?

For answers, I began looking into the Satterfield family, who one way or another appear to be connected to both of my Rebeccas. What I found was a maiden name for Rebecca in Satterfield records. The authoritative book on the family, Satterfield-Sutterfield American Records by Errol T. Lewis, gave the wife of Peter M. Satterfield as Rebecca Sisk. Sisk was also the married name of the aforementioned Rachel who was also probably a Snellgrove.

The book made no mention of the Snellgroves. I found considerably less information on them than the Satterfields. It was not completely "original genealogy" but it was close when I started delving into that family. There was very little on the family online and what was available was largely unsourced, so I had to piece together the family little by little in order to get back to Gasaway and Rebecca Snellgrove.

As it turns out, there was only one Snellgrove family (MAYBE two) in Tennessee during the timeframe I was looking, and the primary family were all residents of a pair of adjacent counties: Wayne and Hardin counties, Tennessee. The Rories were also from Hardin County, so this seemed to fit together well. The apparent progenitor of this Snellgrove family was Hillery/Hillary Snellgrove/Snelgrove [Senior].

There was also a Samuel Snellgrove in the 1820 Census of Warren County, Tennessee. It is unclear who he is or where he fits into the greater Snellgrove family. Since Hillery named a son Samuel, many believe Hillery and Samuel are one in the same and that Samuel is his middle name. There is no proof of this assumption and anyone that lists him as Hillery Samuel Snellgrove in their tree does so to their own detriment. I cannot find records of this Samuel elsewhere, nor of any other Snellgroves in that area. By the 1830s, the only documented Snellgrove family in Tennessee I can find is that of Hillery Snellgrove.

Hillery appears in the 1800 Census in the Newberry District of South Carolina. He is shown to have two males under 10, one female under 10, and one female between 16-25 in his household. By 1810, when he is in the same location, he has 3 males under 10, one male 10-15, one male 16-25, and two females under 10. He is absent from the 1820 Census; I have scoured both South Carolina and Tennessee to no avail. In 1805, he purchased items from the estate of Joab Langford in Newberry District along with Edward, Mark, and John Snellgrove. The same year, he acted as a bondsman along with Josias Duckett for a bond between James Williams and Baruch Odell.

Hillery was married to Patsy Rogers, daughter of Nicholas Gassaway Rogers and Margaret Odell. Both the Rogers and Odell families were among the early prominent families of colonial Maryland. There has been debate as to whether Hillery's wife Patsy was truly the daughter of Nicholas and Margaret Odell Rogers; there were some that applied a different Patsy to the family. It is no longer a point of debate though, because it has been completely proven that Patsy Snellgrove was the daughter of Nicholas Rogers--and the discovery was made by a descendant of the "other" Patsy who believed is ancestress belonged to the Rogers family and disproved himself.

D. Michael Elkins descends from Martha, also called Patsy, who was married to both Jonathan Blakely and later Henry McKelvey, all of Laurens County, South Carolina. Mr. McKelvey later remarried to Nancy Gasaway. His DNA research led him to believe Martha was the daughter of Nicholas Gassaway Rogers and Margaret Odell. Interestingly, this made THREE potential Martha's or Patsy's applied as the daughter of Nicholas and Margaret. The other was supposedly the wife of a Moses Whitten. He set out to prove his theory and ended up...proving that it truly was Patsy Snellgrove who was their daughter.

I was actually ready to rule Patsy Rogers out as Hillery's wife myself due to a record transcription I found online that appeared to indicate a FOURTH possible husband for Patsy, a George Nichols.

[http://genealogytrails.com/scar/newberry/common_pleas.htm]

Honorius Shepard & wife & others vs. Samuel Rodgers
Filed October 1813
Gassaway Rogers died and left the following children: Patsy who married George Nichols, Peggy who married Honorius Shepherd, Polly who married Peter Saterfield, Holly who married James O’Dle, Gassaway Rogers, Sally who married Joseph Shettle, Linah who married Thomas Shepherd, John Rogers, Rachel who married Reginal O’Dle, and Samuel Rogers. (Box 1, Folder A-7)

Michael pointed out that most genealogies of the Rogers family stated that a daughter named Massey Rogers was the one married to George Nichols, but I had no reason to not believe this record transcription. Turns out, the record was indeed mis-transcribed. Michael ordered the original record and found the following [this is his transcription]:

"Shewith that Gassaway Rogers, late of the State and District aforesaid, on or about the [blank] day of [blank] in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and [blank] died intestate leaving a widow who is since dead and the following children to wit: Patsy Rogers who has since intermarried who has since [unintelligible] with Hillary Snelgrove, Nancy Rogers who has since intermarried with William Sheppard, Massey Rogers who has since intermarried with George Nichols, Peggy Rogers who has since intermarried with Honorius Sheppard, Polly Rogers who has since intermarried with Petter Saterfield, Lotty Rogers who has since intermarried with James Odel, Gassaway Rogers, Sally Rogers who has since intermarried with Joseph Shettle, Linah Rogers who has since intermarried with Thomas Sheppard, John Rogers, Rachel Rogers who has since intermarried with Rignal Odle and Samuel Rogers.”

And in order to rule out ANY doubt about this connection for any other researchers, here are scans of the actual documents, courtesy of Mr. Elkins. The pages were on legal-size paper and his scanner only was made for standard size, so there is some overlap to get all the information. Regardless, Hillery's and Patsy's names stand out perfectly removing any doubt of Patsy's connection. And if you haven't already, I hope you'll also note the names of Polly Rogers and Peter Satterfield.


Hillery's parentage is less clear, but I'm not exploring that here. We know based on this^ record that the he was still in South Carolina in 1813. By 1830, he is in Wayne County, Tennessee. His household shows 1 male 15-19, 4 males 20-29, 1 male 30-39, 2 females 15-19, and 1 female 20-29, not including him and his wife. By the 1840 Census, he is still in Wayne County and all children have left his home.

The 1800, 1810, and 1830 Censuses--IF all the enumerated younger people are indeed Hillery's children--indicate his family looks something like this.

1 female likely born between 1780-1784 (probably not his daughter, but possibly step-daughter)
1 male born about 1785-1795
1 male born about 1795-1800
1 female born before 1800 but deceased by 1810
1 female born about 1800 (deceased or married by 1830)
3 males born between 1800-1810
1 female born between 1800-1810
1 male born about 1810
1 male born between 1810-1815
2 females born between 1810-1815

This indicates a probable minimum of 13 children in the family, at least one of whom did not live to adulthood and another of whom was likely not Hillery's child. The 1830 Census indicates that Patsy was older than him, though we don't know by how much. She is 60-69, and he is 50-59. If he is not yet 60 by 1830, then he was born in or after 1770. Therefore even if the 16-25 year old female in his 1800 household was the youngest possible age, she would have been born in 1784 when he was 14 or younger, so she would not be his child. Depending on how much older Patsy was (probably not by too much), perhaps she had a child by a previous marriage, or the woman was a sister, servant, or other relative. So at best, we are looking for at least 12 children of Hillery Snellgrove, 11 or more of whom appear to have reached their teens or adulthood.

Unfortunately, I have only tentatively identified one of the daughters in this family. That would be Martha, born 1809. In the 1840 Census, you can find all the Snellgrove households clustered together side-by-side. Smack in between them all is the household of Wesley Scribner. We find Wesley later in Illinois with his wife Martha, a native of South Carolina. No documentation proves she is a Snellgrove but I believe this circumstantial evidence indicates that.

I believed I have identified five of the seven sons and POSSIBLY a sixth, but probably NOT. The "unlikely" son is a Reginal Snellgrove. If he was a son of Hillery, he would be the oldest because he was old enough to serve in the War of 1812. He came to my attention because he purchased items from the estate of Nicholas Gassaway Rogers. But he more likely belongs to one of the Snellgrove families that moved to Georgia, where his wife later drew a widow's pension for his service.

The other five are pretty straight-forward because they can all be traced back to Wayne and Hardin counties.

1. Samuel Snellgrove, born about 1795
2. Barruch Snellgrove, born about 1805
3. Hillery Snellgrove [Jr.], birth unknown but likely between 1805-1810
4. Gasaway Snellgrove, born about 1810
5. William Snellgrove, born about 1811

That would leave the son born between 1785-1795 (if he was a son and not the spouse of the other 16-25 year old residing in their home), and one son born between 1800-1810.

Barruch appears in the 1840 Census in Hardin County, and after that is found in Cass County, Texas. Samuel and William are both in Wayne County in 1840 and Hardin County in 1850. We have discussed Gasaway. And that brings us to Hillery [Jr.].

Hillery immediately jumps to the front of the pack of "candidates" for Mary's father. His 1840 Census shows 4 children in his home: 1 male 5-9, and three females under 5. Not sure if it can be a coincidence that those perfectly match the ages of Henry, Mary, Martha, and Rebecca.

So here's the facepalm moment for me.


I was thrown off by an 1840 Census entry for "Gashua" Snellgrove in Wayne County. I interpreted the name to be a misspelling of Joshua and that he must be an additional son in the family. It never occurred to me that he would be "Gasaway", and therefore Gasaway was absent from the 1840 Census in my mind. Because I believed Gasaway's appearance in Searcy County with Rebecca b. 1812 was too much of a coincidence, I concluded that Gassaway and Hillery could be the same person. I made him "Gassway Hillery Snellgrove" in my tree WITH A NOTE by his name that said this was a tentative name that needed more research.

That name was absorbed into some public trees, and now a good dozen or more trees reflect this name.


Like I said, nothing I can do about it now. NOW I know there was no "Joshua" Snellgrove. "Gashua" was a phonetic spelling of Gasaway based on how the Census-taker heard the name spoken. We know that because a Gasaway SATTERFIELD was also in Wayne County in 1840, and his name was also written as "Gashua". So Gasaway Snellgrove appears in the 1840 Census, single and childless at age 30-39; he was not the father of the Searcy County Snellgroves all born between 1835-1840. Gasaway and Hillery are two different people, there is no doubt, and Hillery is the best candidate as the father of the Searcy County Snellgroves.

Samuel, William, and Barruch all had daughters named Martha too young to be the one that married Joseph Ward. They all also had daughters named Mary who were all too young to be Mary wife of Jody Rorie. So unless one of the two unknown/missing Snellgrove brothers is the father, none of the remaining known Snellgroves fit. Hillery had daughters of the right age and appears to be our winner. The problem is that he is missing from the 1850 Census.

To backtrack a little, since we now know that Gassaway Snellgrove was the not the father of the Searcy County Snellgroves, we now have sufficient doubt that his wife Rebecca was the mother of our cluster of four. It is plausible that Rebecca was widowed by Hillery, remarried to Gasaway and widowed again, and remarried to a Satterfield and widowed a third time. But the simplest answer is often the best one, and the simplest answer is that Rebecca, the wife of Peter M. Satterfield, was the mother of the Searcy County Snellgroves. She remarried to Peter M. Satterfield, and that is the simplest solution to all this.

So now we have parents for our little cluster. So we're done, right? Not quite. Questions remain that need answering.

When did Rebecca remarry to Peter? Well, I think probably in the early 1840s. Having four children in five years is quite a tear for Hillery and Rebecca. I think the only reason they would have stopped would be because Hillery died. Otherwise, as in Hillery's 12+ sibling family, they would have kept growing their family as much as they could. Sometime after Hillery's death and likely before 1850, Rebecca remarried to Hillery's COUSIN, Peter M. Satterfield. This cousin relationship is proven by the previously shared document naming Polly Rogers Satterfield and Patsy Rogers Snellgrove sisters.

Peter is also missing from the 1850 Census, as are Rebecca and the four children. They were likely all together--wherever they were--which is why they are all absent. Further indicating that Peter came into the (probable) siblings' lives early on is the fact that Henry R. Snellgrove named his first son Peter M. Snellgrove. Peter likely raised Henry from a young age. I think this fact pretty firmly ties Henry as a third sibling to Mary and Martha. Nothing quite so solid ties Rachel to the other three other than genetics--numerous descendants of Rachel Snellgrove Sisk are relatively close DNA matches to my Snellgrove-Rorie lot. My grandmother matches at least two of them at 32/2 and 27.2/2 centimorgans respectively, indicating a 4th-5th cousins relationship indicative of Rachel being Mary's sister. Is it possible Rachel was a cousin to Mary, Martha, and Henry? Technically, yes, but she does fit as a child to any of the known Snellgroves, and again, the simplest answer is often the best one. I do believe Rachel is the fourth and likely final child of Hillery and Rebecca Snellgrove.

So we can reasonably believe Hillery is the father of the Searcy County Snellgroves. And we can believe even more strongly that Rebecca is their mother. But who was Rebecca other than the wife of Hillery Snellgrove and Peter Satterfield? And while we're at it, who was Rebecca, the wife of Gasaway Snellgrove? Disclaimer: From here on out, we venture further from documentation and fact than anywhere else in this article--due to a lack of records, we will be operating in the realm of educated guesswork.

I think the answer for who Rebecca, wife of Gasaway Snellgrove, is is the easiest one of the two. Based on their residence in 1860, I think it highly likely Rebecca was born a Satterfield. That's weird, isn't it? She was likely Rebecca Satterfield Snellgrove, and the other Rebecca was Rebecca ____ Snelgrove Satterfield. Funny how that works, eh?

In his aforementioned Satterfield-Sutterfield American Records book, Errol Lewis states there was an unknown daughter in the Peter M. Satterfield [Sr.] family born about 1814, spouse unknown. In corresponding with Mr. Lewis, he agreed with the assertion that this woman was likely Rebecca b. 1812, wife of Gasaway Snellgrove. Gasaway is still single in the 1840 Census, and Peter M. Satterfield Sr.'s 1840 Census household includes a 20-29 year old woman (and a 20-29 year old man who would be Peter Jr.). Based on Gasaway and Rebecca living with Nathaniel Satterfield and children of John R. Satterfield in 1860, Mr. Lewis and I believe Rebecca is Peter Sr.'s unknown/missing daughter.

John R. Satterfield's children residing in Nathaniel's home in 1860 is noteworthy again because we have no idea where John is. He clearly was a member of the Arkansas Peace Society and conscripted into Confederate service in 1861, but why he is absent in 1860 and his children are dispersed among relatives is a mystery. Three of John's youngest children are residing with none other than Peter Jr. and Rebecca in the 1860 Census, so clearly John is MIA for some mysterious reason but he is not dead. I don't know if we'll ever have the answer to this question, and I have no theories other than...prison or a hospital or other facility, maybe? I really have no clue but thought it worth mentioning.

Before moving on from the Satterfield family for the most part, I want to make one more mention of Nathaniel. For some bizarre, inexplicable reason, he is listed on Find A Grave and numerous Ancestry trees as Nathan Jason Satterfield. Let's get another one of these up in here.


Say this with me slowly, folks: There is not a single record that has been found indicating Nathaniel even had a middle initial, much less had the middle name of Jason. The ONE eyebrow-raising occurrence is that in 1880, Nathaniel appears to have been enumerated on Ancestry.com on the 1880 Census as "John Sutterfield". Unfortunately, the writing on the Census has faded almost entirely. I'm actually pretty impressed that anyone read the name "Sutterfield" through the barely-legible scribbling. Knowing Nathaniel had a daughter named Tennessee based on the 1870 Census and the name Tennessee is pretty legible is really the only way I can find that this household could be identified as that of Nathaniel Sutterfield.

Regardless, if you look at his name on the image itself, it doesn't look anything like John. You can be looking for it to read John, and you won't find it. But if you are looking for it to read Nathaniel, you CAN make out the name Nathaniel.


1880 Census - Campbell, Searcy, Arkansas - Slide 6 of 9. Courtesy of Ancestry.com.

There is no John in this household, only Nathaniel. But someone took this transcription and ran with it, altering the name to Nathaniel John Sutterfield. That magically became Nathaniel Jason Sutterfield, despite the complete absence of any documentation indicating a middle initial, much less a full middle name of Jason. I'm sorry, but I just have to do this again about this whole mess.


Please folks--we have got to stop making up imaginary names for people. Who cares if someone didn't have a middle name?! Not everyone does. But certain researchers over the years have apparently operated under the assumption that EVERYONE MUST have a middle name. And if they can't find one or even an indication of one, they just MAKE IT UP. And that's what this is: a made-up name. Find me a genuine record created while he was still alive that gives a middle initial and I'll Fed Ex you a candy bar of your choice and a handwritten apology for having ever doubted you. I would gladly eat that crow if there was one.

Headstone? N. Sutterfield. 1850 Census? Nathaniel Sutterfield. 1860 Census? N. Sutterfield. 1870 Census? Nathaniel Sutterfield. 1880 Census? Nathaniel Sutterfield. Civil War Service Record? Nathaniel Sutterfield. Civil War Pension record? Nathaniel Sutterfield.

Anyone see any Nathaniel J.'s in there? How about an N. J.? No? Then STOP PRETENDING HIS MIDDLE NAME IS JASON. Jeez folks, just look at your documentation.

Moving on back to Rebecca. There are two main theories online regarding her maiden name. One can be pretty easily disproved, but the other cannot.

Mr. Lewis's book, and at least one other publication as well as numerous online trees give the maiden name of the wife of Peter Moore Satterfield/Sutterfield [Jr.] as Sisk. This is not true, as acknowledged by Errol Lewis himself in our correspondence.

There was only one Sisk family from Wayne County, that of Allen R. Sisk. His son Arthur went on to marry one of our Searcy County Snellgroves, Rachel. Allen was born about 1807, and therefore clearly too young to be Rebecca's father. There are no other known Sisk family ties to this area, so the only other logical conclusion IF Rebecca were a Sick would be to assume she was Allen's sister. The problem with that is that Rebecca gives her birthplace as Tennessee. Not once, not twice, but three times. And Allen's father was Elijah Sisk who can be found in the exact same county in both the 1810 and 1820 Censuses: Surry County, North Carolina. There is zero indication that he went to Tennessee for a couple years, had Rebecca, and came right back to North Carolina. Therefore, there is no reason to believe Rebecca's maiden name was Sisk.

That brings us to the next option. Some Wayne County, TN researchers pointed me to the name Shipman. Specifically, they posited that she was the daughter of Jacob Shipman. Now, the Snellgrove family does have one documented connection to the Shipman family. Samuel Snellgrove was married to Susan Shipman. But she was not the daughter of Jacob; she is said to be the daughter of David Walden Shipman. Susan was apparently (and I need to stress that I have not personally verified this genealogy work) the half-first cousin of Jacob Shipman. She was reportedly the daughter of David Walden Shipman, son of Daniel Shipman by one of his wives. By another of his wives, this same Daniel was said to be the father of a Jacob, who was the father of another Jacob that is believed to have been the father of Rebecca.

This would not be a terribly close connection between Susan and Rebecca, but it is worth mentioning.

Jacob Shipman was the progenitor of a large Shipman family, many of whom made their way from Wayne County, Tennessee to Searcy County, Arkansas and the surrounding areas, just like the Sutterfields. This family includes Isaac, John, William, James Ervin, and Matthew Shipman. Some also believe that John R. Satterfield's wife, Martha, was a Shipman and daughter of Jacob; other researchers give her maiden name as Treece, but there is no proof for either name. Another woman, Elizabeth wife of Daniel Berry of Wayne County is believed to be a daughter of Jacob.

It is necessary to note that there were TWO Jacob Shipmans in adjacent counties whose records are often mixed together. Jacob Shipman of Perry County is NOT Jacob Shipman of Wayne County. A Jacob Shipman is in the 1820 Census of Perry County at age 45+. Our Jacob Shipman [the one who could be Rebecca's father] is not located in the 1820 Census, but in 1830 he is aged 40-49, so these are not the same man. Two Isaac Shipmans also appear with Jacob of Perry in 1820. A possible third Jacob appears in Perry County in 1840 as a 50-59 year old. For this to be the same Jacob as the one in Perry in 1820, he would AT LEAST have to be in the 60-69 category if not older if he was already 45 or older 20 years before 1840.

It is likely all these Shipman families intersect at one place or another. They may all connect back to the aforementioned Daniel Shipman, I'm not sure. I have not thoroughly researched this family. But Jacob of Wayne does name one of his sons Isaac as well. It will take research that I don't have the time to undertake currently to work out how all the Shipmans might connect to one another. But it was important to clarify that there were two Jacobs in relatively the same age range in adjacent counties, though the Jacob of Perry was older and appears to have had more children than Jacob of Wayne.

The aforementioned Daniel Shipman, a supposed half-uncle of Jacob of Wayne, is also in Wayne County in 1830 among a family of 14. His household is four pages from that of Jacob and another Shipman, an unknown William who would be an age to be Jacob's son but a different William b. 1821 is more likely Jacob's son. This 1830 Census appears to be one of the main reasons it is believed Rebecca was a Shipman because Jacob Shipman and Hillery Snellgrove [Sr.] are enumerated as living next door to one another.

Add that to the theory that John R. Sutterfield's wife Martha was a Shipman (this seems to be at least in part based on their son Isaac having a middle initial S., and another Isaac S. Sutterfield in the family has a documented middle name of Shipman) and there are some interesting coincidences at the least. Jacob's son Matthew Shipman was yet another member of the Arkansas Peace Society along with the Satterfields and Gasaway Snellgrove. There is also the fact that Jacob Shipman certainly has a 15-19 year old daughter in the 1830 Census that has not been identified.

Lastly, we know that the Shipmans and Satterfields were linked by familiarity at a bare minimum. In 1851, Mary "Polly" Rogers Satterfield, now the widow of Peter, applied for a Bounty Land Warrant based on Peter's service in the War of 1812. Among her witnesses was none other than Jacob Shipman, who stated he had known Mary for 26 years (so since roughly 1825, indicating both families had arrived in Wayne County, TN by that time). [Source: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/shipmanresearchers/message/3902]

Was Rebecca a Shipman? That is not proven or clear. Genetically, it seems highly likely. My grandmother, her brother, and their first cousins were 3rd great grandchildren of Rebecca, probable wife of Hillery Snellgrove and wife of Peter M. Satterfield. If Jacob were her father, he would be their 4th great grandfather and just within range of being picked up in autosomal DNA. We match numerous descendants of Jacob Shipman, in particular one cluster provided by researcher Don P. Shipman, who has submitted numerous relatives' DNA. We match many of his provided samples, all of whom appear to be Jacob Shipman descendants.

In closing, I need to dispel one last case of bad genealogy. Here is our last one of these.


Our ancestress Rebecca, mother of the Searcy County Snellgroves and wife of Peter Sutterfield, is buried in the Freeman Cemetery in Stone County, Arkansas. She is buried near her daughter, Rachel Snellgrove Sisk. She died 30 Apr 1893 according to the stone which says "Aunt Becca Sutterfield". It appears to have been placed not by her children by nieces or nephews for whatever reason. Three of her nieces by marriage to the Sutterfield family are also buried there.

For some bizarre, inexplicable reason, the Find A Grave memorial for Rebecca has been linked to a Nathaniel Sutterfield. Not the aforementioned one, but a much younger one, born 1857, the son of Henry P. Sutterfield. This younger Nathaniel did married a Rebecca in 1881 in Searcy County. This might all work if not for the fact...that Nathaniel's wife Rebecca is STILL ALIVE IN 1900. You know, 7 years after the stone says Becca Sutterfield died. Funny enough she's still alive in 1910...and 1920...and 1930 in Oklahoma! But some genius thinks that someone gave her a stone and said she died more than 35 years before she did. People just astound me sometimes.

I lied, I gotta throw one more of these in for good measure because this is just such a ridiculous error.


Okay, I really am done this time.

I hope this essay has provided some measure of clarity for those researching this family. If additional information comes to light, I will add it as-needed. If anyone has additions or corrections, feel free to contact me.